Based inYonkers, New York

Local time--:--:--

Behance ↗LinkedIn ↗

Start a project
Featured projectNike × KOI × Air Max Release

(Creative direction)

Creative Director vs Art Director: What's the Difference?

By Rinor RamaCreative direction3 min read

(In short)

  • A creative director owns the idea; an art director owns the execution
  • Creative directors answer for whether the work works, art directors for how it looks
  • On small teams one person often does both.

A creative director owns the idea: what the work should say and why anyone should care. An art director owns how it looks and makes sure every piece meets that standard. I've worked on both sides of that line, as Creative Director at Fyre Festival and as a social media designer at Nike, so here is how the two roles split in practice.

What does a creative director do?

A creative director sets the direction for a brand, a campaign or a launch. In practice that means turning a business goal into a creative idea, deciding what the work should feel like before anyone designs it, leading designers, writers, photographers and art directors toward one vision, presenting and defending the work with clients and leadership, and making the final call on what ships. The creative director is accountable for whether the work achieves what it was meant to, not just whether it looks good.

What does an art director do?

An art director turns the idea into a visual language and makes sure every piece is executed well. That means defining the look of a campaign, shoot or product, directing photographers, illustrators and designers, choosing type, colour, layout and imagery, and checking every asset before it goes out. Art directors are usually closer to the craft and spend more of their time inside the work itself.

The US Bureau of Labor Statistics describes the role in similar terms: art directors are responsible for the visual style and images in publications, advertising, packaging and film, and direct the people who produce them.

The key differences

  • Focus: the creative director owns the idea and strategy; the art director owns the visual execution
  • Scope: a creative director covers the whole campaign or brand across every medium; an art director usually leads the visual side
  • Team: a creative director leads the whole creative team, including art directors and copywriters; an art director leads designers and visual contributors
  • Accountability: the creative director answers for whether the work works; the art director answers for whether it looks right and stays consistent
  • Career path: many creative directors started as art directors or copywriters.

Which one does your project need?

If you already know what you want to say and need it to look exceptional, hire an art director or a senior designer. If you're not sure what the campaign or brand should be, or you need someone to lead several people toward one idea, you need a creative director. On smaller teams and independent projects one person often does both. That is how I usually work: setting the direction, then staying hands-on through the final files.

You can see that mix of direction and hands-on design in client work like the Nike × Kids of Immigrants Air Max release and the WXC+ website for Microsoft. Whoever you hire, a clear brief helps: here is how to brief a designer.

Frequently asked questions

Is a creative director more senior than an art director?

In most agencies and in-house teams, yes. Art directors typically report to a creative director, although titles vary between companies.

Can one person be both?

Yes, especially on small teams, at startups and on freelance projects.

Do you need a creative director for a brand identity project?

For a complex rebrand or a launch with many moving parts, it helps. For a focused identity, a senior brand designer who thinks strategically is often enough.

Need a creative lead for a launch or campaign? See how I work as a freelance creative director.

Rinor Rama

Rinor Rama — independent brand designer and creative director in New York with 13+ years of experience. Collaborations include Nike, Microsoft, Google, Brent Faiyaz and Don Toliver.Behance · Dribbble · LinkedIn

(Related work)

Seen in practice.

Tell me what you're building — I'd love to help.

Rinor Rama

Rinor RamaBrand designer & creative director

Contact

Let's connect